Sarah's Key blog #2

The characters from Sarah’s Key, Night, and The Boy in the Striped Pajamas have many similarities. For example, all 3 of the protagonists from the stories are Jewish young adults/children. They were all innocent prior to the holocaust, and emerged mature. The protagonists are all brave and family oriented. Furthermore, all of the main characters are very questioning, thus providing opportunities for the reader to ask themselves along with the protagonist, “How could this injustice be tolerated?” I believe that for all intents and purposes, the characters might as well all be the same person. Although they have different experiences, they are all typecast as the strong-willed, ‘life-is-hard-but-I’ll-make-it-through’ Jew that people want to read about.

Just as their characteristics are similar, so are their motivations. One of Elie Weisel’s primary motivations to continue living was his family’s welfare, whilst Shmuel wanted desperately to find his father, and Sarah is constantly worried for her younger brother. This proves that since the protagonists lost almost all that was important to them, they would not let their families be taken away from them as well. Also, all of the characters are motivated to simply live, and to get back to their normal lives before the troublesome times of the war.

Finally, proving my initial point that all of the fictional protagonists are loosely based off of the same Elie Weisel type of character, their experiences are generally the same as well. Sarah, Elie, and Shmuel were all taken to Concentration Camps and lost various members of their families. The main characters all lost their childhoods to the war, and never had much of a chance to enjoy being a kid. All of the documented experiences of the Jewish protagonists include them coming in contact with someone that is losing his/her mind, as a literary tool to show how severe the times were. I believe that I would enjoy reading a holocaust novel that depicted the main character with more faults and insecurities, thus making him/ her more human, but I can understand why the author doesn’t typically do that, as it could be seen as a betrayal to the brave Jews of the era.

Sarah's Key Blog #1

Hello blog enthusiasts! I write to you now, post-completion of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, at the introduction of Sarah’s Key by Tatania De Rosnay. I hope for Sarah’s Key to be a better read than The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. Before I begin to discuss the characters, setting, and problem of my new book, I would like to mention several complaints that I have about my previous book choice. First off, I find it extremely simplistic and historically inaccurate that Bruno, the nine year old protagonist of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas would be so annoyingly innocent throughout the book. It is unreasonable to believe that a German boy, let alone a son of a Nazi Commandant, wouldn’t be enrolled in Hitler Youth and be force-fed the ideals of the Nazi Regime. He would have grown up under the supposition that Jews, gypsies, and homosexuals belonged dead. Bruno would have believed that Shmuel was a filthy Jew, and he never would have made friends with a boy that was inferior to the Aryans.

Anyway, now that I have expressed my discontent with the flawed brainchild of a historically inaccurate author, ‘tis time to divulge the details of Sarah’s Key. As of yet, the plot of the book shifts by chapter between the life of an as of yet unnamed French girl who lived during the holocaust, and a middle aged American woman living in France with her family in present day. Thus far, while Julia, the American woman, has been busy discussing the possibilities of renovating the house that used to belong to her grandmother in law, the story of our other protagonist, the unnamed French girl, has been much more thrilling. Our young heroine was awoken by a French policeman knocking on her door, telling her family that they have 10 minutes to pack all of their things before they are forced to leave their home. While the girl and her mother surrender themselves to the policeman, her younger brother and her father go into hiding. At the sight of his wife and daughter walking away, never to be seen again, the father relinquishes himself as well, leaving his son trapped in a hideaway beneath the floorboards, presumably to die. The setting for both of the plot lines is Paris, France. Julia’s plotline’s problem is undefined, whereas the problem of the other girl’s plotline is that she is being forcibly taken to a concentration camp because of her religion. The characters themselves are all quite flat at the moment, and the author is using the writing style of dropping the reader into the story with little background knowledge about the characters.

The Boy in the Striped Pajamas Blog #2

Hello blog readers! When I last concluded reading my exciting assigned portion of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas by John Boyne, our protagonist, Bruno, had just moved into his new home. Since my last blog installment, very little has happened. In a short, the last 4 chapters consisted of Bruno inquiring about the ominous and unfriendly looking Concentration Camp near his house, and his family refusing to make the situation clear to Bruno. I have recently made several inferences from the text. Throughout the introduction of the book, Bruno’s sister Gretel was not referred to by name, but simply referenced as the “Hopeless Case.” I inferred that Gretel had a mental illness, as in the early 1940s, people (Nazis are no exception) were less accepting of those with disabilities. I also infer that the place next to Bruno’s house that has only been described as “a nasty place…” (37) with a “very high fence…” (31) and “no greenery anywhere to be seen in the distance…”(32) is a Concentration Camp. When Bruno asked his father to tell him who the people behind the fence were, his father clearly stated, “They’re not people at all.”(53) This leads me to conclude that the mysterious place next to Bruno’s new house must be a Concentration Camp, as Bruno’s father is a commandant in the Nazi regime, and it is common knowledge that the Nazis thought of Jews as if they weren’t people, but were rather a scourge, plaguing the superior Aryans. I have one question of the text as of right now.  My question is, “What string of events will lead Bruno to encounter the title character?”  Throughout the duration of the book, Bruno has often fantasized of running away from his new home, back to Berlin, and I believe that it will be this desire to get away that will lead Bruno to lose his way and end up at some part of the perimeter of the Concentration Camp. Bruno is also a curious child, and I think it is also a possibility that his curiosity got the best of him, and he took a stroll down towards the Concentration Camp.

Boy in the Striped Pajamas Blog 1

The story, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas by John Boyne opens with a boy named Bruno encountering his maid packing all of his things into several suitcases. Bruno learns that he and his family are going to leave their friends and old lives in Berlin behind to move far away. Bruno is saddened by this idea, but the only explanation of the relocation is that his father’s job is taking him to a new area in Germany. Upon Bruno’s family’s arrival in their new home, Bruno is appalled by the lack of greenery and cheerful things in the vicinity. I ended my assigned reading with Bruno’s shocking discovery that his new home is actually right next to a Nazi concentration camp. Bruno is a polite and curious 9 year old boy who lives in Berlin during the early 1940s. Throughout the entirety of the book’s introduction, Bruno has only ever been depicted with semi-angelic qualities. Although he was reluctant to move away from his three best friends for life and his house with the large bannister that he would so frequently slide on, he never argued with his parents about this new change in lifestyle, and he decided to adapt to the situation at hand. His often mentioned (yet never physically depicted) father has a high-power job in the Nazi regime, as evidenced by the following quote, “…The large dining room where the Fury had been to dinner the week before.”(p.2)  As of yet, no real problem has emerged from the plot, although I do believe that since Bruno has just discovered the Concentration Camp, conflict in the plot lies ahead.